The Black Eyed Peas vs. Bryan Pringle

Thanks to Eleanor for submitting this one

After some quick googling it looks like this one was in and out of court. I’m sure The Black Eyed Peas‘ team of lawyers  outnumbered Pringle’s 100 to 1 on this. I had a hard time finding any info about Pringle so if anyone has anything  please post in the comments.

Bryan Pringle in 2010 sued the Black Eyed Peas and several co-defendants, including record labels EMI April Music Inc. and Interscope Records; French DJ David Guetta, who co-produced several Black Eyed Peas songs; and several music publishing companies.

Pringle contended that the hip-hop group had ripped off “Take a Dive,” which was copyrighted in 1998, particularly a “guitar twang” melody, or “hook,” that he added in a dance version of the song he composed in 1999. However, Pringle could not obtain copyright registration for the dance version because it was deemed to not be substantially different from the original, according to his complaint.
read more at law360.com

 

The Black Eyed Peas - "I Gotta Feeling" (2009)

Bryan Pringle - "Take a Dive" (1998)

I also found this more recent info. I’m not sure how these legal fees work but all I can seriously think is WHAT A WASTE OF MONEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  IS THIS WHAT PEOPLE ARE SPENDING MILLIONS OF DOLLARS ON??!

LOS ANGELES (CN) – A federal judge awarded Black Eyed Peas songwriter will.i.am $1 million in costs and attorney’s fees for defending against a claim that the band infringed copyright in the 2009 hit, “I Gotta Feeling.”

The judge awarded another $1.3 million in attorney’s fees to the band’s producer, and $50,000 to the record label.
Read More  HERE

 

facebook comments (wordpress commenting below)

Some Ads here...Conversation about this post below..
This entry was posted in litigated, Music by Keith. Bookmark the permalink.

9 thoughts on “The Black Eyed Peas vs. Bryan Pringle

  1. avatarMark Adams

    You may not remember this, but Arthur Delgado submitted this two years ago to the day.
    http://www.thatsongsoundslike.com/2011/02/23/snow-patrol-vs-theblack-eyed-peas/comment-page-1/#comment-2245

    [Reply]

    avatar

    Keith Reply:

    Heh. Well that’s silly. I even replied to him! I guess I should’ve posted this then!!

    [Reply]

    avatar

    Mark Adams Reply:

    I think you might have done a similar thing with Flo Rida vs Katy Perry.

    [Reply]

  2. avatarKelly H

    How did they not settle for something? I mean, this is worse than “sounds like”: it’s an exact copy. The worst part is that they didn’t even steal it to make a GOOD song.

    [Reply]

    avatar

    Mark Adams Reply:

    I have found Walk Hand in Hand was first recorded by Denny Vaughan (1956), even before Andy Williams, Vera Lynn and Tony Martin, who had the biggest hit with it, according to Wikipedia.
    http://www.secondhandsongs.com/work/118891/all#nav-entity.

    [Reply]

    avatar

    Mark Adams Reply:

    Sorry, I’ve attached the wrong comment here. What I meant to say was that they aren’t good songwriters, so they need people to sample. Most of the time the song that samples is inferior as the ‘artist’ doesn’t know how to build on the sample, but sometimes they do and I guess the same goes for all derivative works.

    [Reply]

    avatar

    Keith Reply:

    Kelly, I’m guessing it’s because the Black Eyed Peas have a LOT more money than Pringle to fight it in court.

    [Reply]

  3. avatarMark Adams

    It seems BEP are inconsistent in crediting their sources and asking permission. I don’t know if it has anything to do with how well known the songs they sample are, or not, but how is it easier to get away with using a sample without permission if they don’t credit it? The original artist will notice when they hear it anyway.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Eyed_Peas

    [Reply]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *